Zen

Chau-Yin Temple (關西潮音禪寺)

Four-Faced Buddha (四面佛) 

It is a short scooter drive from my place in Taoyuan south into the mountains of Hsinchu county to the popular old village of Neiwan (內灣) Most people take the train from Hsinchu, or they drive their car and get stuck in massive traffic jams or lines getting in and out of the village.

I can't even count how many times I've driven over on a Sunday and sat in a little tea shop drinking Hakka Lei-Cha (客家擂茶) and eating peanut sticky rice (客家麻糬.) I just take the short drive on my scooter, pass all the cars on the road there and don't have to pay for parking! Its always a win-win situation. 

Guanyin (觀音)

My drive to Neiwan takes me through another Hakka town called Guanxi (關西) I noticed over the past year or two that a strange (non-Taiwanese-looking) temple popping up over all the other buildings in the village.

It looked like they were constructing some sort of temple, but was nothing like Taiwan's traditional temple architecture and the entrance was always blocked, so despite being nosy and wanting to figure out what it was, I just looked at it from afar each time I passed by and gradually it seemed to become more and more reminiscent of a Buddhist 'Wat' (temple) from Thailand.  

Temple protector

The temple has since opened and my suspicions have ultimately been confirmed. The temple really is a "Thai-style" temple and is the first of its kind in Taiwan which probably makes it pretty special.

At this point, I should probably remind my dear readers that Taiwan and Thailand are of course two different countries. One is in East Asia and the other is in South East Asia

(You don't know how many times I've had to answer this question!)  

The temple is named Chau-Yin Temple (關西潮音禪寺) and has recently completed construction and officially opened to the public.

The original Chau-Yin Temple was built in Guanxi in 1913 and was a simple Ch'an (Zen) Buddhist monastery in an old style ‘three section house' (三合院.) 

From the research I've done about it, it seems like the abbot of the temple and some followers went to Thailand for quite a few years and upon their arrival back in Taiwan decided to construct a new residence for their growing numbers of monks and nuns.

They decided that they would build a Thai-style temple to reflect their time spent in Thailand and would replace the modest monastery that they had used for decades which had become dilapidated. 

(Left-Right) Medicine Buddha, the Buddha, Amitabha

The grounds of the temple are quite large and it is next to a river bank which provides a natural surrounding to the temple despite being close to the main road through Guanxi.

When you enter the main parking lot of the temple you are met by a giant 19 meter high sitting Guanyin statue (pictured above) as well as a small outside hall with several stone Buddha statues. Through the main gates there is a small shine to the 'four faced Buddha' (四面佛) and further on is the main building with its beautiful white walls and red roof. 

There isn't really much to see in the monastery other than the main shrine room. Its a functioning monastery with both monks and nuns, so you can't really wander around through people's living quarters.

When I visited, I just checked out the main shrine room and greeted a few of the monks and nuns living there with smiles. They probably weren't expecting a foreign guy to be walking through so they seemed a bit curious to see me walking around. 

The main shrine room has a pretty large shrine to the Medicine Buddha (彌勒佛), the Shakyamuni Buddha (釋迦牟尼佛) and Amitabha (阿彌陀佛) which are all represented in the Burmese Mandalay style and a bit different than what you'd normally see in Taiwan. 

Outside of the temple is probably the main attraction for Taiwanese people which is is the shrine to the so-called "Four-Faced Buddha.

Erawan Shrine in Bangkok

Phra Phrom or The Four-Faced Buddha (四面佛) has become popular recently in Taiwan with shrines popping up all over the place. I have thought it was a strange phenomenon for a while now, but with so many random street side shrines popping up (I can think of at least 8 different shrines off-hand) I thought there must be a reason for it, so I tried to do some research.  

The photo above is a shot I took in Bangkok at the Erawan shrine last year. The Erawan shrine is an extremely popular spot in urban Bangkok for people to visit. The shrine is thought to bring good luck and health to all who visit, so as you can imagine, whenever you go, you'll find a lot of people both Thai and tourist alike. 

Here is a description of what the statue means and what it looks like: 

  • The four faces symbolize the four books of the Vedas, the Hindu scriptures and the source of all knowledge in the creation of the universe.
  • The eight hands, symbolize the omnipresence and power of Lord Brahma.
  • The upper right hand carries a rosary, symbolizing the cycle of life from creation to death. The upper left hand carries the Vedas, symbolizing knowledge and intellect.
  • The lower left hand carries a pot of water representing cosmic energy of creation. The lower right hand bestows grace and protection.
  • Reference Link

Four-Faced Buddha (四面佛) 

The confusing part of the whole thing is, that the Four-Faced Buddha isn't actually even a Buddha at all - its an image of the Hindu god Brahma. 

To explain my confusion you have to understand that Buddhism as a philosophy splits itself into a couple of schools of thought. The first is Theravada which is the 'original' Buddhism and is most popular in South East Asia. Followers of this school strive for their own personal enlightenment whereas in Mahayana (which is more common in Tibet, China and Japan) followers strive for the enlightenment of all living beings through compassionate actions. 

This is of course a very simplistic explanation of both schools and I could go much more in depth about them, but the key point apart from their differences is that both Theravada and Mahayana Buddhism are atheistic in nature and do not accept the notion that there are any deities let alone a divine creator.

So why is Brahma, the Hindu divine creator being worshipped by Buddhists? 

I believe this is an issue of cultural assimilation. You may accuse me of nitpicking, but Buddhism should at its core reject the idea of gods - but since Thai culture has had such close interaction with Indian culture, there has been a sort of cultural assimilation of many aspects of Hinduism in Thai culture and the Brahma image in this case.

My confusion in the matter lies in the fact that, it was okay for Thai Buddhists which adhere to Theravada Buddhism to assimilate Brahma into their practice, but why are Mahayana Buddhists, especially these Ch'an Buddhists in Taiwan doing the same?

Chau-Yin Temple (潮音禪寺)

Is it a matter of cultural assimilation? The effects of globalization? 

For me, I would take a stab in the dark and explain it like this: The Taiwanese and Chinese culture as a whole are very superstitious. They tend to be very interested in things that bring good luck and try to avoid things that are said to bring bad luck.

The shrine at Erawan is famous throughout Asia for bringing great luck to the people who visit so the spread of the four-faced Buddha throughout Asia thus has nothing to do with the statue being a "Buddha" or Hinduism spreading through Asia and more a matter of convenience for people who can't always travel to Bangkok. 

For the longest time, Taiwanese people would travel to Japan to visit UNIQLO, Hong Kong for H&M, Zara and a few other international brands. Globalization however has brought these brands to Taiwan and has reduced the need for people to travel in order to buy the things they want. 

If you look at it like this, bringing Phra Phrom to Taiwan just might be a great way to bring wealth, good health and prosperity to the country if you're prone to believe in these kinds of things.  

So, if you are superstitious, you just might get excited about that. If not, just remember that the teachings of the Buddha were ultimately just guidelines to follow and were never meant to be a religion. You can do whatever you like with your life as long as you treat others with respect and compassion. 

No matter how you feel about this kind of thing, if you have a chance, be sure to visit Taiwan's only Thai-style temple - It is beautifully constructed and of course quite unique in Taiwan's religious scene. 

If you have any questions, or you want to tell me how absolutely wrong I am about my conclusions, please feel free to comment below!  


Gallery / Flickr (click for higher res) 


Getting There

 

Yuan Guang Temple (圓光禪寺)

I spent a lot of time growing up studying the various forms of Buddhism and how the philosophy varied from country to country - That interest ultimately led me to become involved with Shambhala, a Buddhist group started by a Tibetan Lama who had escaped to the west just after the 1959 uprising in Tibet. I don't consider myself a Buddhist, nor do I follow any other religion, but I have a lot of respect for the core values of the philosophy.

I didn't actually spend that much time learning about the spread of Buddhism in Taiwan so when I arrived in Taiwan, one of the things that quickly became a hobby was visiting all the various temples and taking the time to enjoy the treasure troves of traditional Taiwanese art inside them. I often tell people that there is not much you could learn in a museum about Taiwanese history that you wouldn't learn from a Taiwanese temple. 

One thing that interests me about the temples here is that you often find several different religions all housed within the same building coexisting peacefully.

People have argued with me that all these religions (Buddhism, Taoism, Confucianism and various folk religions) all are more or less derived from each other or at least related therefore there is no need to have conflict with each other- but to that I would counter: Are Judaism, Christianity and Islam not related?

I personally believe that this is not a reflection of the religions you find here, but a testament to the kind of people you find in this country and that these trivial arguments and wars we have in the west over religion are pointless.

When it comes to Buddhist monasteries in Taiwan however I start to get a bit confused as to what is actually going on inside them. Buddhism is rooted in a philosophy of living a simplistic non-material life, and if you become a monastic, that simplicity and lack of materialism is supposed to go to the extreme. 

I find that the major Buddhist organizations in Taiwan (Dharma drum mountain (法鼓山), Fo Guang Shan (佛光山), Tzu Chi (慈濟) and Chung Tai Shan (中台山) all seem to subscribe to some strange notion of modernity and take the Vatican’s “bling bling” approach to religion which to me seems a bit ironic considering the way Buddhists should adhere to a lack of attachment to worldly objects.

Any visit to these monasteries in Taiwan tends to be a bit overwhelming at the displays of opulence put on by these organizations. These displays of monetary wealth likely go hand in hand with Chinese culture and I guess it shouldn't be that surprising to see that they take the “go big or go home” attitude towards life that is a reflection of the Chinese notion of having “face.”

I think the the majority of the money spent on these massive palace-like monasteries would be better spent on charity and improving the lives of the poor. 

One group that doesn't seem to go overboard with their decadence is the “Yuan Kuang” (圓光) Ch'an Buddhist group here in Taoyuan. 

Ch'an Buddhism (禪宗) is better known in the west as “Zen” and had its origins in 6th Century China before it spread to Korea, Japan and Vietnam centuries later. 

The Yuan Kuang temple was established in 1918 during the Japanese Colonial period by a monk named Miao-Guo who was so influential at the time that he was invited to Japan to teach the Japanese royal family.

When he came back to Taiwan he built the Yuan Kuang Temple here in Zhongli (中壢) and through it he attracted young people to experience monastic life while at the same time offering high school and college education courses to them. Since 1987 the temple has been renovated and they have started to expand the school to an area near the monastery where they are now offering graduate courses. 

The design of the main temple stresses simplicity. When you walk in you are greeted by a statue of the Laughing Buddha known here in Taiwan as Mi Le Fo (彌勒佛) with a paved walkway to the steps of the temple with a garden on both sides. The front of the temple has a modestly sized statue of the Buddha of Compassion Guanyin (I say modestly sized because most of the temples mentioned above have statues taller than 75 meters.)

When you walk up the stairs you are greeted by the entrance to the shrine/meditation room with some small statues of the Buddha at the door as well as an incense burner in the middle. 

The shrine room is beautiful, but once again it stresses simplicity and doesn't go overboard like the other monasteries I've visited. It's very quiet inside and there is always a nice breeze coming in through the windows. For an organization that has obvious weath, its refreshing to see the Yuan Kuang group maintaining a simple monastery and not expanding to the extent that many of the other monastic orders in Taiwan have succumbed to. 

If you plan on visiting the temple, you are more than welcome, but I stress that this monastery has quite a few monastics, so turn off your cellphone ringer and be quiet to respect the people who are trying not to fall asleep while meditating. 

If you're travelling through Zhongli, the Yuan Kuang temple is a nice stop over for an hour or so. The people there are kind and they don't push religion on you, tell grandiose stories or ask for donations like so many other places like this do.

The map below shows how to get to the monastery, it is a short drive from Zhongli or the Taoyuan High Speed Rail station. I don't think there are buses that run through the area, so it would be best to arrange your own transportation. 

 

Website: 圓光禪寺 (Chinese-Only) 


Gallery / Flickr (High Res Shots)